Research Paper: Quality Coaching Employs Critical Thinking

A Research Paper created by Steve Gardner
(Executive Coaching, UNITED STATES)

Critical thinking is not negative or closed thinking; it is disciplined thinking. Paul and Elder define critical thinking as “the art of analyzing and evaluating thinking with a view to improving it.”1 Fisher and Scriven define critical thinking as “Skilled, active, interpretation and evaluation of observations, communications, information, and argumentation.”2

Critical thinking begins by being critical of your own thinking. Start where you are now. Consider your normal thinking process and complete the statements in this box.

If you are skilled in the art of critical thinking, you may self-identify multiple problems and fill pages with answers. If you are not, you may have difficulty finishing the first sentence. What does this reveal about the current state of your normal thinking process?

Imagine a child who was born with a serious vision problem. Her condition would be her norm, and she would have no knowledge of any deficiency without some means of comparison with others. Innocent ignorance would consign her to a lifetime of unnecessary challenge; competent testing would reveal the deficiency and enable corrective glasses to resolve it.

Realizing that the way you think is as natural to you as the way you see or hear, consider these questions with regard to your thinking.

1. How much of your thinking is vague, inconsistent, illogical or superficial?
2. Are you in control of your thinking process?
3. Do you have any standards for testing it?
4. What could you teach about how to think?

Critical thinking is “self-directed, self- disciplined, self-monitored, and self- correcting.”3 It is not a tool you add to a repertoire of problem-solving skills; it is a second layer you add onto your thinking—a diagnostic layer that analyzes the thinking process itself.

No matter how well you currently think, you can learn to think better. This requires being intellectually humble, which is aided by recalling opinions you once held strongly but have since disproven.

If you recognize that you have subconscious biases, blind spots, and a tendency to be over- influenced by what those around you say, you are in a better position to engage in these basic elements of critical thinking:

•  Formulate clear, focused problem statements.
•  Gather and assess relevant information.
•  Separate assumptions and facts, examining and verifying appropriately.
•  Use logical reasoning to draw inferences.
•  Test conclusions against relevant criteria and standards.

In summary, critical thinkers routinely practice two broad thinking processes:

1. Identify and challenge the assumptions underlying beliefs and behavior.
2. Explore and imagine alternatives to current ways of thinking and living.4

Since your thinking is crucial to everything you do, want, or feel, it is worth engaging in the intellectual work required to improve it.

1 Paul, Dr. Richard; Elder, Dr. Linda. (2007) The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking Concepts and Tools. Dillon

Beach: Foundation for Critical Thinking Press, p. 4

2 Fisher, Alec and Scriven, Michael. (1997) Critical Thinking: Its Definition and Assessment, Center for Research in

Critical Thinking (UK)/Edgepress (US). p. 20

3 Paul and Elder. The Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking Concepts and Tools, p. 4

4 Brookfield, Stephen D. (1987) Developing Critical Thinkers. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.