Call +61 403 600 248

International Coach Academy

Coach Training School

  • Regions
    • USA & Latin America
    • Canada
    • Asia
    • Australia & NZ
    • United Kingdom
    • Europe
    • Africa
    • India
    • Middle East
  • Language
    • English
    • Italiano
    • 课程选择
  • Contact
  • OUR SCHOOL
    • Training Methodology
    • Our Story
    • Faculty
  • PROGRAMS
    • Advanced (150hrs)
    • Professional (125 hrs)
    • Vocational (76 hrs)
    • Workplace (60 hrs)
    • Bridging (BYO prior training)
    • Alumni (Lifetime Member)
  • STUDENT LIFE
    • Learning Online
    • Flexible Schedules
    • Industry Experience
    • Your Coaching Model
    • Your Coaching Niche
    • FlipIt Coaching Framework
    • Business Building
  • COACHCAMPUS
    • Inside CoachCampus
    • ICA Coaches
    • Graduate Yearbooks
    • Student Support
  • RESOURCES
    • What is Coaching?
    • Certification & Credential Guide
    • Coaching Power Tools
    • Coaching Models
    • Coaching Research
    • Library
    • ICA Blog
  • Join Login

Articles, Case Studies & Interviews

You are here: Home » COACH PORTFOLIOS » Research Papers » Research Paper: Coaching the Toxic Leader

Research Paper: Coaching the Toxic Leader

2014/10/15

research paper_post_raymond lefort_600x250
Research Paper By Raymond Lefort
(Executive Coach, CANADA)

Article Title:

Coaching the Toxic Leader, Four pathologies that can hobble an executive and bring misery to the workplace-and what to do about them. By Manfred F.R Kets de Vries, April 2014, Harvard Business Review

Article Summary

The article draws attention to the role senior executives have in creating a work environment where employees feel satisfied and make a contribution – or one where the environment can be dysfunctional and employees are unhappy. The impact an executive can have depends on his or her mental state, where good mental state leads generally to appropriate corporate rules and unhealthy mental state generally leads to a more dysfunctional organization. The author describes four pathologies that he has encountered in his coaching practice: the narcissist, the manic –depressive, the passive-aggressive and the emotionally disconnected. Drawing from examples in his practice, the author describes each pathology and describes possible behaviours that are often associated with the pathology and the approach used to coach an executive who is afflicted by the pathology. A summary of each is provided below.

Pathology Type Recognizing the Condition

Coaching Approach

Narcissist

  1. Are selfish and inconsiderate
  2. Have a sense of entitlement
  3. May have grandiose fantasies about themselves
  4. Pursue power and prestige at all cost
  5. Are viewed as a “user”
  6. Have a binary view of the world- “for” or “against” them
  7. Have a tendency to idealize or devaluate
  8. Avoid upsetting their sense of self. Start by placing his/her self-esteem on a firm footing
  9. Avoid re-enforcing grandiose self-perception
  10. Once trust is gained you may begin to confront him/her on individual behavior dysfunction
  11. Use his/her ambition to motivate him/her

Manic-Depressive

  1. He/she appears to have no emotional middle ground- High highs and Low lows
  2. Creates an environment of “perpetual firefighting”
  3. May have tendencies for substance abuse
  4. Medical treatment history
  5. Poor insight of how their behavior impacts others and how they are perceived
  6. Usually treated with psychotherapy and medication. May be used in conjunction with coaching
  7. Make him/her confront the reality of their relationship with others
  8. Draw and work with others affected to create new structures
  9. Seek his/her permission to obtain feedback from colleagues on how he/she is perceived to develop awareness in him/her

Passive-Aggressive

  1. Expresses negative feelings indirectly
  2. Covertly express resentment: late for meeting, misses deadlines, sabotage behavior
  3. May view others around them as unreasonable
  4. Low self-esteem
  5. Accept defensive reaction while pointing out inconsistent behavior – “It seems to me that you are angry?…”
  6. Allow space for him/her to reflect on behavior / comments
  7. Build up self-esteem. Practice directness and ask he/she to explain how to resolve /improve situations they find themselves in

Emotionally Disconnected

  1. May lack emotional intelligence
  2. Seems detached from emotions – may lack intimate relationships
  3. Not in touch with his/her emotional responses.
  4. Build a trusting relationship with him/ her
  5. Review events or circumstances in daily life to bring about reflection and awareness around the feelings of others around him
  6. Have him/her describe difficult encounters at work or other setting to describe which part of the experience brings emotional response.
  7. Group and other forms of therapy may be useful

The author also explores in the article the differences between coaching and therapy.  He describes where various perspectives on this topic “draw the line”- one distinction being that coaching is based in the conscious and therapy on the unconscious.  On this point he concludes

But it’s my conviction that therapist can benefit from knowing more about the organizational world, and coaches without training in psychology would do well to acquire its basics.[1]

Review

This article is interesting from many perspectives.  First, looking at my personal career and work experience it was interesting to be able to gain a greater understanding of leadership impact.  Having worked in organizations where sometimes the leadership was wonderful and sometimes more toxic, I found it useful to gain a better understand of various predominant pathologies in leadership, their impact and the coaching approach to use in each.

Since the beginning of my ICA journey I have wondered about the marriage of consulting and coaching. Though I have not reached a “conclusion” for myself on this topic I am developing a sense that, as in many disciplines, the more tools at our disposal the greater the effectiveness of our interventions with our clients can be. The author of the article brings an interesting new perspective. While ICA advocates a clear segregation of therapy versus coaching, the author advocates a marriage of the two disciplines as appropriate. Given the authors wide background in Economics, Management, Psychoanalysis this bias was not surprising to me. In the end, I believe its about having the proper training-that is don’t try to be a coach or a therapist without the proper training.

Take away from the article:

  • Good leadership is grounded in a healthy view of ourselves and our impact on others.
  • Coaching can be an effective tool to bring about greater awareness and change executive behavior to lead to healthier organization. In large organizations this is no small feat!
  • Organizations need to develop greater awareness of the “health” of their executive cadres.
  • In my own consulting practice, I now have a new set of tools to help deal with difficult executives supported by the coaching skills I am continuing to acquire.
  • Bringing more skills to my coaching practice will help make me a better coach.

[1] Kets de Vries, Manfred, F.R. (April 2014). Coaching the Toxic Leader. Harvard Business Review, Page 9.

Filed Under: Research Papers Tagged With: coach canada, executive coach, leadership coaching, raymond lefort

How We Train

 

Read More About e-Learning at ICA

Course Guide

Fill out my online form.

Search

Categories

About Our School

Become a Coach
Coaching Niches & Specialities
Our Methodology
Faculty
Class Schedules
Online Community

 

Resources

What is Coaching?
Certification & Credentialing Guide
Graduate Research Papers
Graduate Yearbooks

Locations/Contact

Global: Clik Collective
Asia: Duo Tower
Postal: PO Box 3190 Mentone East,
Melbourne AUSTRALIA, 3194

Email: [email protected]
Questions: Ask here

Copyright © 2023 · International Coach Academy ·

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
  • OUR SCHOOL
    • Training Methodology
    • Our Story
    • Faculty
    • Back
  • PROGRAMS
    • Advanced (150hrs)
    • Professional (125 hrs)
    • Vocational (76 hrs)
    • Workplace (60 hrs)
    • Bridging (BYO prior training)
    • Alumni (Lifetime Member)
    • Back
  • STUDENT LIFE
    • Learning Online
    • Flexible Schedules
    • Industry Experience
    • Your Coaching Model
    • Your Coaching Niche
    • FlipIt Coaching Framework
    • Business Building
    • Back
  • COACHCAMPUS
    • Inside CoachCampus
    • ICA Coaches
    • Graduate Yearbooks
    • Student Support
    • Back
  • RESOURCES
    • What is Coaching?
    • Certification & Credential Guide
    • Coaching Power Tools
    • Coaching Models
    • Coaching Research
    • Library
    • ICA Blog
    • Back